“I’ve never actually tried gelato,” I tempted the GPYY girls. “What if we go to Tempo Gelato? Closest one from here is in Tamsis.” We were planning to hang out properly — a pity to meet up and just have iftar and go home.
“What about Artemy?” Nanas suggested somewhere else.
“Where’s that?”
“Near Pasar Kranggan.” I had a faint memory of it — Rio had recommended it once when we were riding around the city with nothing particular to do. He’d suggested this over Tempo Gelato because it has more to offer than just ice cream.

“Works for me,” Nadya agreed.
Good Location, Comfortable Space
Milk by Artemy looks like a typical contemporary Jogja hangout spot. Plain white walls, indoor plants in every corner. Staff in matching aprons with a red M logotype. Located at Jln. Kranggan No. 58, with roadside parking managed by a juru parkir. Strategically placed near the city’s tourist centre, close to Tugu Pal Putih.
Despite being relatively new, they already have a second branch on Jln. Prawirotaman 1 No. 16 — I’d vaguely noticed it while cycling through the tourist district once.


The furniture is well-arranged: a mix of high and low tables. Large windows, hanging plants and potted greenery, furniture tones matched to the square-patterned floor — aesthetically consistent from every angle. Several corner setups designed for photography. Some tables were already reserved by other groups.
Five accessible areas: ordering room, main room, perfume room (my name for it — there’s a display of perfume bottles in various scents), smoking area, and bathrooms. The main room has air conditioning, but it wasn’t running very cold — pandemic protocols discouraged heavy AC use. Smokers could use the eastern room. We settled at a high table in the main room to look at the menu.





A Lot of Flavour Options
First time with gelato — I stood in front of the display case a long time. Staff waited with a tasting spoon. Twelve flavours visible behind the glass, and apparently that’s only the daily selection: the café has around 90 recipes, rotating 12 each day to keep things interesting. Beyond gelato, the menu includes pancakes, waffles, toast, spaghetti, burgers, cookies, and crepes. Drinks cover green tea to jasmine tea, coffee, chocolate, and milk-based options. A large glass pitcher of complimentary water sits on the counter for after your gelato.
I chose orange and rum raisin — two scoops for Rp27,000 (before 10% tax). Pricing is by portion size: small (1 scoop) Rp22,000, medium (2 scoops) Rp27,000, large (3 scoops) Rp32,000. I’d considered going large, but the Rp5,000 increment between each size doesn’t create the kind of psychological push toward the bigger option that a good decoy effect would. If they priced it better, I’d have gone large. 😅






How Was It?
Honest assessment: not quite what I’d call authentic gelato. The texture was softer than standard ice cream, but the flavour profile felt closer to regular ice cream than true gelato — possibly from lower milk fat content, or the orange flavour being too dominant. The rum raisin worked better for my palate; the raisins were tender when bitten. The main issue: the room temperature wasn’t cold enough, and the gelato melted faster than I wanted.





The others each went different directions. Mbak Eno ordered oreo mixed with lemon — found the oreo too sweet. “The lemon tastes like Split candy from primary school,” she said, which is entirely accurate nostalgia. Ucha tried green tea and oreo — agreed the oreo was too sweet, felt the green tea flavour was underwhelming. Nadya, who’d been before, got choco mint and orange blood — “Tastes like stomach medicine mixed with children’s cough syrup,” she said, without particular disappointment. She recommends Artemy more as a dessert hangout than a gelato destination. “The texture is closer to ice cream anyway. And it melts fast.”
The space is genuinely nice. Even the bathroom is photogenic. Worth coming back for the atmosphere even if the gelato itself sets modest expectations.
