A market is one of the economic poles of a community — its magnetic field defined by the pull and push of supply and demand. Traditional markets have historically served as the backbone of local exchange: places where money circulates through small traders, where prices are negotiated, where social interaction accompanies economic transaction. That role is under sustained pressure from modern retail.
Indonesia has around 23,000 modern retail units — 14,000 minimarkets and 9,000 supermarkets — against 13,450 traditional markets serving approximately 12.6 million small traders. AC Nielsen data from 2007 showed modern retail growing at 31.4% per year, while traditional markets were contracting by 8% annually. Sustained over time, that trajectory points toward the disappearance of traditional markets as a functioning economic institution — and with them, the livelihoods of millions.

Ridwan Kamil’s Market Revitalisation Agenda

As Mayor of Bandung, Ridwan Kamil incorporated local economic development and UMKM (small and medium enterprise) support into his mayoral vision. Through PD Pasar Bermartabat — Bandung’s city-owned market management body — the programme aimed to convert traditional markets into places that competed with modern retail not just on price, but on experience: cafes and food courts to encourage people to stay, free WiFi to enable digital monitoring of food stock and attract younger visitors, and physical redesign to make market buildings more ergonomic and appealing.
The programme would provide stalls for existing traders and new ones, with no distinction in placement — an attempt to level the field rather than privilege incumbents. Digital integration would also let city government monitor food supply availability in real time.
Bandung has 40 traditional markets. Of those, 27 lack clear ownership certificates under PD Pasar, creating administrative complications that slow the revitalisation process. Some markets — including Pasar Sarijadi — have been revitalised and are available as early case studies.
The Corruption Problem
Physical revitalisation, however, is only part of the problem. PD Pasar itself was implicated in a corruption case involving inflated fees for market kiosk licence renewals — Rp120,000 charged against a legal rate of Rp22,000, and name-transfer fees tripled from Rp400,000. The total corrupt extraction: Rp1.6 billion, drawn from 17,000 traders across 27 markets. The victims, as always in these schemes, were the small traders the institution was supposed to serve.
Revitalising the physical market without restructuring and cleaning up the institution managing it produces limited results. For the programme to deliver on its promise of economic equity between traditional and modern retail, PD Pasar needs to be reformed alongside the buildings.
The deeper question — whether market revitalisation is sufficient on its own to preserve the role of traditional markets in Indonesian urban life — remains open. But it’s the right question to be asking, and the Bandung experiment is one place to look for early answers.
